Glossary

    Glossary

    Sole Trader vs Company

    A sole trader is you with an ABN - profits taxed at your marginal rates, no liability wall, no administration. A company is a separate taxpayer at 25 or 30 percent: deferral and a liability wall, at the price of compliance.

    TaxLast reviewed 2026-10-04

    What it is

    A sole trader is the simplest business structure in Australia: you, with an ABN, trading in your own name. The profits are your personal income, taxed at your marginal rates, and the business's debts and liabilities are your debts - the house is on the line. There is no separation between you and the business, which is the simplicity and the exposure at once.

    A company is a separate legal taxpayer. It pays a flat 25 or 30 percent on its profits, retains what it does not distribute, and its debts are its own - the shareholders' exposure ends at their investment, unless they have signed personal guarantees. The price is administration: annual returns, directors' duties, a separate tax file number and the accounting that keeps the separation honest. Both structures register for GST once turnover passes $75,000.

    Key takeaways

    • A sole trader is you with an ABN: profits taxed at your marginal rates, debts are personal.
    • A company is a separate taxpayer at a flat 25 or 30 percent, with its own debts.
    • The company rate is a deferral: the top-up to your marginal rate waits until the dividend.
    • The liability wall ends at the company's investment - unless personal guarantees were signed.
    • Both structures register for GST once turnover passes $75,000 in a year.

    How it works

    The mechanics run on the same profit through both structures. $120,000 of profit as a sole trader is personal income: taxed at the marginal scales, roughly $28,920 including the Medicare levy, leaving $91,080. The same $120,000 inside a company at 25 percent is $30,000 of tax and $90,000 retained - a near-identical first-year outcome, with the difference arriving later: the company's retained profit compounds pre-top-up, and the sole trader's surplus is fully post-tax from day one.

    The liability difference is the structural one. A $50,000 claim against a sole trader is a $50,000 personal debt - the house, the savings, the lot. The same claim against a company is the company's debt, and the shareholder's exposure ends at their investment unless a personal guarantee was signed. The wall is the reason businesses with premises, employees or public exposure incorporate, and it is the reason insurers ask about structure.

    The compliance is the price. The company needs an annual return, directors' duties under the Corporations Act, a separate TFN and bank account, and the Division 7A discipline on drawings; the sole trader needs an ABN and a tax return. Both register for GST within 21 days of passing $75,000 of turnover, and both pay PAYG instalments once the ATO's threshold is met. The sole trader tax calculator prices the sole trader side, and the australian income tax calculator runs the personal scales.

    Why it matters

    For an Australian reader, the structure decision is a risk and profit decision, not a vibes decision. The sole trader structure is free and simple and personally exposed; the company is a few hundred dollars of ASIC fees and accounting a year, and it walls the liability. The deferral is the second lever: the company's retained profits compound before the top-up tax. The GST threshold of $75,000 applies to both, and the gst registration entry covers the 21-day rule.

    A colleague named Brent (yes, that Brent) sole-traded a fencing business through three profitable years, then wore a $60,000 insurance dispute personally because the claim was lodged against him, not a company. The house was the collateral the structure never had. The highest-leverage thing most Australians can do is match the structure to the exposure - incorporate when the liability or the profit justifies the compliance, and stay a sole trader while the risk is genuinely small. The sole trader tax calculator prices the simple side first.

    Real-world examples

    The first-year tax arithmetic: $120,000 of profit

    As a sole trader, $120,000 of profit is taxed at the marginal scales - roughly $28,920 including Medicare - leaving $91,080. Inside a company at 25 percent, the tax is $30,000 and $90,000 is retained. The first year is a rounding error apart; the difference arrives later, when the company's retained profit compounds pre-top-up and the sole trader's surplus is already fully post-tax. The deferral is the part that compounds. The structure pays for itself on the deferral and the liability, not year one.

    The $50,000 liability wall

    A $50,000 claim against a sole trader is a personal debt: the house and the savings are on the line, and the insurance dispute is lodged against the individual. The same claim against a company is the company's debt, and the shareholder's exposure ends at the investment unless a guarantee was signed. The wall is the reason the structure exists, and it costs a few hundred dollars of ASIC fees a year.

    The 21-day GST registration both structures share

    Turnover passes $75,000 in October, and both structures must register for GST within 21 days. The registration is backdated to the registration date chosen, and the 10 percent GST on sales after it is collected for the ATO whether or not the pricing included it. The gst registration entry covers the threshold mechanics, and the margin is the part that absorbs the GST that was never priced.

    Common mistakes

    Mistake: Staying a sole trader past the point where the liability matters.

    Why it bites you: The business's debts are personal, and the house is the collateral the structure never had. Brent's $60,000 insurance dispute was lodged against him, not a company. Incorporate when the exposure justifies the compliance.

    Mistake: Incorporating for the tax rate while paying everything out as salary.

    Why it bites you: The deferral only exists on retained profits: a company that distributes everything pays the top-up at the shareholder's rate. Price the deferral before the structure is chosen - the structure costs its compliance and defers nothing.

    Mistake: Ignoring the $75,000 GST threshold.

    Why it bites you: Registration is due within 21 days of passing the threshold, and the GST is owed on sales after it whether or not the pricing included it. Check the threshold monthly, not yearly - the margin absorbs the backdated bill.

    Mistake: Mixing personal and business money in one account.

    Why it bites you: The mixing dissolves the separation that makes the company a company, and it makes every reconciliation a forensic exercise. Separate accounts are the compliance that keeps the wall standing.

    Ivy's take

    I spent an evening with the ATO's structure pages and a calculator, running the same $120,000 through both structures so you don't have to. The first year was a rounding error apart - $28,920 against $30,000 - and the real difference arrived later, on the liability wall and the deferral. The structure decision is not a tax decision; it is a risk decision with a tax discount.

    Brent's fencing business is the case study in the other direction: three profitable years, then a $60,000 dispute worn personally because there was no wall. The compliance is the price of the wall, and the wall is the product. Match the structure to the exposure, register for GST on time, and let the structure be boring.

    Related jargon, defined

    ABN
    The Australian Business Number, the sole trader's registration with the ATO.
    GST registration
    Mandatory within 21 days of turnover passing $75,000, for either structure.
    Limited liability
    The company's wall: shareholder exposure ends at the investment, unless guarantees were signed.
    Division 7A
    The rules deeming company drawings to shareholders as unfranked dividends.
    PAYG instalments
    The pay-as-you-go tax instalments on business and investment income.
    Directors' duties
    The Corporations Act obligations directors owe the company, not the shareholders.

    Frequently asked questions

    Should I be a sole trader or a company?+

    The decision is a risk and profit decision: sole traders are simple and personally exposed, companies wall the liability and defer tax at the cost of compliance. Incorporate when the liability or the retained profit justifies the annual fees.

    How is a sole trader taxed?+

    Profits are personal income, taxed at your marginal rates with the Medicare levy on top: $120,000 of profit carries roughly $28,920 of tax. There is no separation between you and the business.

    What does a company protect me from?+

    The company's debts are its own, and shareholder exposure ends at the investment unless personal guarantees were signed. It does not protect against directors' duties, and it does not protect the sole trader structure at all.

    When do I need to register for GST?+

    Within 21 days of turnover passing $75,000 in a year, whichever structure you trade through. The 10 percent GST is owed on sales after the threshold whether or not the pricing included it.

    Is the company tax rate always lower?+

    Not always: the 25 percent rate defers the top-up to your marginal rate rather than erasing it, and a company that pays everything out as salary gains little. The rate is flat, which is the difference from the personal scales.

    Disclaimer: This information is general in nature and does not constitute financial or legal advice. Always consult a qualified professional for your specific situation.

    Keep learning

    Ivy Sinclair-Wren

    Ivy Sinclair-Wren

    Financial Chaos Analyst

    Connect on LinkedIn

    Ivy Sinclair-Wren is a Financial Chaos Analyst covering investing, AI, wealth psychology, and the emotional consequences of opening finance apps during market crashes. Based in Melbourne, she specializes in demystifying the Australian tax code and helping users navigate the intersection of spreadsheet logic and human irrationality.